Starve the Mail, Starve the Town: The Quiet Case for Rebuilding the Post Office as Public Infrastructure
Photo by Photo by Tolga deniz Aran on Unsplash on Unsplash
There is a particular cruelty in the way America defunds the things it claims to love. The United States Postal Service is, by nearly every measure, a triumph: it delivers to roughly 160 million addresses, six days a week, to every rural crossroads and every urban high-rise, at universal rates. It has topped Gallup's polling as the most trusted federal institution for years, holding public approval that presidents and Congresses can only envy.
And yet for two decades, the institution has been governed by a premise borrowed from private equity: that the mail is a business, and a failing one, and that the correct response is shrinkage.
The Mandate That Manufactured the Crisis
The fiscal story is well known but worth restating precisely, because the framing matters. The Postal Accountability and Enhancement Act of 2006 required USPS to pre-fund retiree health benefits decades in advance — an accounting obligation no other agency, and essentially no private company, carries in that form. The 2022 Postal Service Reform Act corrected the worst of it by eliminating that pre-funding schedule, a genuinely bipartisan fix that progressives correctly fought for.
But the deeper wound is philosophical. Under Postmaster General Louis DeJoy's 10-year plan, the agency has pursued service standard rollbacks — slower first-class mail, consolidated processing facilities, reduced window hours at post offices. USPS's own performance data showed first-class delivery times degrading as these changes took hold. The logic is circular and deliberate: degrade service, watch volume and trust decline, cite the decline as proof the agency must shrink further.
Who Loses When the Mail Slows
The people harmed are not the people making the decisions. Rural residents, elderly Americans, disabled veterans, and low-income households without reliable broadband depend on the Postal Service for medications, benefit checks, ballots, and — not incidentally — the last regular, human, physical touchpoint with their own government. When a processing plant consolidates and a town's mail arrives a day later, that's an abstraction in a quarterly report. It's a missed chemotherapy shipment in person.
Compare this to how we treat other infrastructure. Nobody demands that rural highways turn a profit. Nobody proposes that rural electrification be subject to market discipline. The universal service obligation is the entire point of a postal system; if we only wanted profitable mail, we could simply let UPS and FedEx divide the country and abandon the rest.
The Counter-Argument, Honestly Stated
Defenders of the cost-cutting approach make a real point: USPS has faced genuine financial strain, mail volume per household has fallen dramatically from its 2001 peak, and a rigid workforce model in a shrinking market is not sustainable forever. Declining to ever change anything is not a plan.
But the strongest version of their argument still concedes the crucial point: the problem is a revenue model, not a mission. And that's where the progressive alternative is stronger than mere defense.
The Affirmative Case: Build It Out, Don't Shrink It Down
France's La Banque Postale is one of the clearest precedents: a postal bank that grew into one of France's major retail banks, serving millions of customers including many unbanked or underbanked people the commercial system ignored. Roughly 4.5 percent of American households were unbanked per the FDIC's most recent National Survey — disproportionately Black, Hispanic, and low-income households paying billions annually in check-cashing and predatory lending fees. Postal banking, which the USPS itself studied in a 2014 white paper and which Inspector General analyses have repeatedly revisited, could offer basic accounts and small-dollar credit through existing post office infrastructure — 30,000-plus locations, many in precisely the banking deserts where the need is greatest.
Add expanded services — passport processing at scale, broadband-adjacent services, notarization, secure document handling — and the universal network becomes an asset instead of a liability. The post office stops being a legacy cost and becomes what it was designed to be: civic infrastructure with a revenue floor.
The direction of the country is legible in how it treats its most trusted institution. A nation that starves its Postal Service while its richest citizens get same-day everything has made a choice about who counts. Fund the mail. Expand it. And treat the last daily knock on America's doors as the public trust it actually is.